Lightboxes, Then the World
Monday, September 10th, 2007Once again, 37signals peers down from their ivory tower and tells us all how we should be doing something. Do they sell software or ego?
This time, Ryan (last name here) decides that he hates lightboxes. Apparently, his eyes are so sensitive that he gets a strobe light effect from just viewing some screenshots. What else would we expect from someone whose applications are perfect in every way.
I could stomach this righteousness if his blog post gave any inkling of solving the problem of displaying screenshots in an attractive way. It doesn’t. He just complains and, I suppose, keeps the secret magic to himself. Instead, we are to infer that a long page which we scroll through to see screenshots is better.
Snark aside, I see benefits to both approaches. If the lightbox is done well, as in it has gallery functions to move through a set of pictures, it has merit. The long scrolling page can be done well as long as there are some good visual cues to separate image and its accompanying text from the next set of image/text.
However, just declaring from the heavens that lightboxes are evil just smacks of the same old 37signals papal decree.
Technorati Tags: 37signals, lightbox, screenshots, pope